Introduction
You may be forgiven for not being familiar with the acronym IDOR. The term behind the acronym, Insecure Direct Object Reference, doesn’t help much either, unless you happen to be a programmer.
Putting this is a more comprehensive way, IDORs are unintentional pathways that can expose sensitive data and functions to users who shouldn’t have access. So, they are important to hackers.
A metaphor for IDOR
Imagine your business as a building with multiple rooms, each holding different types of sensitive information. Only certain employees have keys to specific rooms, based on their roles. All well and good. Now, let’s imagine we have a door inside the building that accidentally connects two rooms, allowing someone unauthorized to sneak into sensitive areas simply because the door wasn't properly secured. Not good! And neither is IDOR!
In this post, we’ll explore how IDOR vulnerabilities can undermine business security, why they pose a significant risk, and how to secure your business against them.
Understanding IDOR Vulnerabilities
IDOR occurs when applications reference sensitive resources, like URLs or database entries, without adequate access controls. It’s akin to leaving a service door unlocked in a building, allowing someone to access files or resources they aren’t authorized to see.
IDOR vulnerabilities primarily arise from insufficient access control mechanisms in a web application. These issues occur when that applications fail to adequately verify a user’s permissions to access specific resources, relying instead on predictable identifiers or URLs. Key causes:
1. Lack of Authorization Checks
Often, applications may skip rigorous authorization checks, assuming that if a user has access to one resource, they should access similar resources. This oversight can allow unauthorized users to access or modify data by altering URL parameters or identifiers.
2. Predictable Identifiers
Using predictable object references, such as sequential user IDs or order numbers, makes it easy for attackers to guess or brute-force different references to access unauthorized resources. When identifiers are exposed in URLs or APIs without obfuscation, attackers can simply increment or decrement values to retrieve other users' data.
3. Client-Side Control Assumptions
Some applications incorrectly assume that access controls implemented on the client side (e.g. in JavaScript or front-end validations) are sufficient, without enforcing these controls on the server. Attackers can bypass these client-side restrictions by manipulating requests directly to the server, highlighting the need for strict server-side authorization.
4. Inadequate Role-Based Access Control (RBAC)
Applications that lack robust RBAC or attribute-based access controls may unintentionally grant access to unauthorized users. Without proper user-role mapping and permissions enforcement, even ordinary users can perform admin-level actions or view sensitive data.
5. Insufficient Testing and Security Audits
IDOR vulnerabilities often go unnoticed during development if security testing is insufficient. Regular security audits, code reviews, and penetration testing are essential for catching these flaws early.
So, there is plenty that can be done, to prevent IDOR.
IDOR in Practice
In web applications, IDOR vulnerabilities commonly occur in URLs or API endpoints where sensitive resources are identified by predictable references.
Consider the following URL: https://companyportal.com/userprofile?id=101
In a vulnerable system, an attacker might change the id=101 to id=102 to see another user’s profile. This clearly must be prevented as such a manipulation allows the attacker to unlock unauthorized doors, and see confidential data without even needing the intended user permissions. Consequences:
· Exposure of Sensitive Information: Imagine an intruder walking through the unlocked door and finding client information or company finances. IDOR vulnerabilities can expose similar sensitive data, leading to significant privacy and regulatory consequences. Allowing users to view each other’s profiles or transaction data could violate regulations like GDPR, resulting in fines and penalties.
· Damage to Brand Reputation: The discovery of IDOR-based security issues can erode customer trust. If clients find out their data was accessed due to poor access control, they may lose faith in the business, leading to lost revenue and reputation damage.
· Manipulation of Business Operations: in more severe cases, attackers can use IDOR to alter data—such as changing prices or order details. This is comparable to an outsider walking into a room and editing confidential documents or operational processes.
· Legal Liabilities and Compliance Penalties: Depending on the industry, IDOR vulnerabilities can result in compliance violations with data protection laws and leading to legal repercussions. Protecting sensitive data is a legal responsibility, and leaving these “back doors” open could lead to costly lawsuits and penalties.
Real-World Examples of IDOR Vulnerabilities compromising systems
· Facebook: A vulnerability allowed users to access private photos of others by tweaking the URL. This IDOR oversight left a back door open for unauthorized viewing of sensitive content.
· Uber: In 2016, IDOR allowed attackers to access details of other users’ rides simply by altering trip IDs in URLs. This simple exploit exposed private travel information to unauthorized users.
How to Secure Your Business Against IDOR Vulnerabilities
Just like you’d check every door in a building to ensure it’s locked, protecting against IDOR requires a thorough approach to access control and data validation.
· Implement Robust Access Controls: Ensure that every “door” (or data resource) checks that users are authorized to access it. This means implementing server-side authorization for each data request, validating whether the user has permissions to access the requested information.
· Use Indirect Object References: Rather than using visible identifiers like order IDs or user IDs in URLs, switch to opaque references (like tokens or hashed values) that attackers can’t guess or manipulate. For instance, replacing id=101 with a unique token prevents an attacker from easily accessing another user’s data.
· Conduct Regular Security Audits: Just as a building may undergo routine security checks, regularly assess your application through penetration testing and code reviews to catch any IDOR vulnerabilities before they’re exploited.
· Monitor User Activity: this will flag suspicious access attempts to help detect any manipulation attempts. For example, if a user repeatedly tries to access other user IDs, it could indicate an IDOR attack in progress.
· Educate Development Teams: Just as a security team needs to know how to keep a building safe, developers should understand the risks associated with IDOR vulnerabilities and follow best practices. Conducting regular security training and code reviews can reinforce secure coding practices, minimizing the risk of IDOR.
Conclusion
IDOR vulnerabilities are like leaving an unattended back door to sensitive areas, allowing unauthorized access and potential manipulation of critical information. For businesses, this could mean data exposure, compliance penalties, and loss of customer trust. By taking a proactive stance on security, businesses can ensure these “doors” remain securely locked, protecting both their operations and their customers.
Useful Links:
Article on IDOR Vulnerability:
NCSC information on Cyber Essentials:
ICO (Information Commissioners Office) guidance on data protection:
Comments